Excellent coming-of-age novel by Canadian writer Elizabeth Hay, set in the time of the Quebec independence referendum. Hay works very hard to distinguish the characters, and it usually works, except I couldn't quite get a handle on the mother, who was the main character. The book is really sad in many ways - lots of death and lots of coping with less-than-optimal relationships, but there is hope here too and I will try some of her other books.
ho hum, too long, too humdrum, reminded me of Danielle Steel's style of writing (I read half of book of hers years ago)
But then, Danielle Steel's output is in the top five in all the world and all time!
Both authors have lots of fans...... but count me out.
"His Whole Life" by Elizabeth Hay was a novel I enjoyed immensely. While I have read it just the once, I think it ranks up there with my all time favourites. I love how it balances a specific historical moment while exploring Nan and her relationship with her son Jim, questions of her marriages, questions of her friendships and a whole lot more. Quite the complex novel and yet very absorbing.
I can't wait to reread this book in a few years. Even though personally connected to the geography and timeline I whole heartedly recommend it to others
I absolutely LOVED this book. It is so beautifully written, I found myself pausing every few pages just to take in the language, often writing down quotes and sharing them with anyone in earshot.
I also connected to the timing of the story, set during the backdrop of the 1995 Quebec referendum which was around the time I came of age politically and, like Nan, I watched events unfolding in agony, fearing that my country would be torn apart.
I was also intrigued by the question that arose throughout the book, "what is the worst thing you've ever done?". It occurs to me that most of us have not done one truly horrible thing but in considering the question, the criteria we chose to determine our worst things says a lot about what we value. I have used this question to think about my own life and start conversations with other people around me.
I can't wait until Elizabeth Hay comes to speak at our library in October 2017.
This is a"quiet" book, gracefully written, with above all a compelling sense of place. Hay infuses with love those parts of the book that are set in the woodlands and lakes that those of us living in the southern fringe of central Canada colloquially refer to as "north" (although in geographic terms this is certainly not true north, that vast arctic and sub-arctic landscape that makes up much of this country). That lovingly painted setting alone is likely to endear the book to those of us who have shared that life experience and treasure it. Her accounts of life in Manhattan are, as to be expected, less atmospheric.
I seldom comment on titles but in this case I feel compelled to do so: The book covers a period of eight or nine years in the life of a boy. I assume her intent was to present those years as formative, which of course they are, but I still find the title awkward, not doing the book justice.
The boy, Jim is skillfully drawn and we get to know him very gradually -- even at the end we are left with the feeling that there are aspects of him that have yet to be revealed. The author clearly loves this boy very much and she wishes us to share that love.
The book is also about a marriage that doesn't really work and about the myriad tiresome ways that family members hurt each other, often seemingly without any coherent purpose. Therein lies stark realism, balancing the heart-on-sleeve lyricism that pervades much of the book ; Hay is no Pollyanna. Finally, the book is set in a very real and specific time, that of the Quebec referendum, a period that most of us would be just as happy to forget; but that too lends an air of authenticity.
Reading this book requires a bit of patience; excitement there is not. But it succeeds on several levels and merits four stars.
Enjoyed the Canadian content and the wonderful interaction of mother and son.
This I rate as a perfect book. Elizabeth Hay writes with great insight and compassion about ordinary people and the challenges in their lives. Highly recommended.
A simply written book about conflicting feelings and views about family and politics. Alternating debate about family relations, feelings, secrets, feuds, and Canadian politics watched by a growing ten year old boy. Humorous mocking passages about Canadians. Honest feelings, no false niceties, and still not bitter.
I like the way Hay writes about adolescent boys. enjoyed the inclusion of the Quebec referendum and the characters' differing opinions.
good book. worth the wait.
I have enjoyed all of Hay's novels.
There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.