Select language, opens an overlay

Comment

Community comment are the opinions of contributing users. These comment do not represent the opinions of the Edmonton Public Library.
Apr 07, 20161_Great_Book rated this title 3 out of 5 stars
I think Chevalier is in a slump. I absolutely LOATHE Sadie Goodenough and she could have been cut from the story completely. Plot and style of writing vary - it's like 3 mini stories grouped together, and goes from first person vernacular free-flow thinking to vague details in badly written letters, to third-person impersonal narrative by the end. The apple tree story really doesn't have anything to do with the sequoia/redwood story, other than planting things in developing America. I am disappointed in this variance from Chevalier's usual tight, well-balanced narrative on more interesting topics with better developed characters. Her themes from European history better are much better than this American one.